Who sucks worse dave gilmore or rodger waters?

is any one else besides me getting sick of rodger waters rehashing old pink floyd songs, he never could sing, now(live earth concert) he,s got some guy on a black & tourtise fender rippin out the hot b licks to old p/f tunes,so he,s obviosly lost his touch,granted dave should have left his last release on the island where he found it, but at least he tryed something new,